54-56. The Books of Ember

The City of Ember
The People of Sparks
The Prophet of Yonwood

By: Jeanne Deprau

These books are apparently the big hit of the 'young adult' fantasy world right now, and the first book is currently being made into a movie with Bill Murray. Our fourth graders are reading the first one as a class as part of their curriculum this year.

The City of Ember exists alone in an empty world. Outside the walls of the city is just darkness, and daylight is provided by large electric lamps that click on and off at prescribed times. The city is stocked with canned goods and other necessary items, but nothing new is created (with the exception of some withered greenhouse vegetables). In the city is a box, and the box has a key that will save the people from darkness when the time comes. Only the box has been lost, and its existence forgotten.

The first book creates a world that is at once unique and original as well as a dark shadow of our own. Its powerful stuff for young readers who can appreciate its implications. Unfortunately, while the second two books continue to explore the theme, the world they exist in is not nearly as unique, and the message thus falls somewhat flat. The People of Sparks continues the story of the people of Ember, and is mildly satisfying as a follow-up, although cannot hold a candle to its predecessor. The third book The Propet of Yonwood is not very satisfying as a prequel- its obvious and slow; however, it does raise interesting issues for young readers about the difference between faith and fear, and for that it can be worth reading. However, without its two predecessors, theres not too much to support it.

The Book of Ember though, is an engaging read for any age even if the secret of ember becomes quite clear for adults much quicker than it will for kids.