Friday, September 19, 2008

19. The Hollow Hills


By: Mary Stewart

Mostly Merlin just wanders around and prepares for book three. Sort of like the hobbits in Lord of the Rings.

Grade: B
Recommendation: Slog on through to the sequel.

3 comments:

Doc said...

I had a slightly higher opinion of these than you did (A-). Anyway, shouldn't this be 19-20-21. After all, they are three separately published books collected under one cover. Give yourself some credit!

dsgran said...

Thanks Doc, I only read the second one (in full) still getting through the third one. I did enjoy it, but for me it was no where near as good as the first book.

OlmanFeelyus said...

Late, I know, but you are so wrong about this book. It surpasses the first in my opinion. Here Merlin is finally fully confident of his abilities. He has grown up and just dominates. All the "wandering around" that you call it is an incredibly rich story of political machinations, careful diplomacy and subtle espionage in the stirring, inspiring milieu of the young Britain slowly becoming aware of its promise as a nation. Plus, the detailed and compelling descriptions of the locations are immersive and help complete the total escape that this great fantasy novel provides.